Episode Ratings Grid

M
Loading chart...
Excellent
Great
Good
Mid
Bad
Awful

Episode Power Rankings

The peaks and the valleys. Find the essential episodes — and the ones to skip.

#1
S6E28 9.0
The Tom Tuesday Story

While scouting in Wyoming territory, Duke is forced by outlaw Tom Tuesday to act as his guide to an important rendezvous in Ruby City, Idaho. Tuesday is going blind from a gunshot wound, and Duke is able to turn the tables on him.

#2
S8E18 9.0
Herman

The wagon train comes across old Jamison Hershey and Herman, his 3,000-pound Belgian horse. The old man has made it safely through hostile Indian territory because the tribes are so in awe of his horse. Hershey and Herman are invited to ride with the train, though it becomes apparent that Herman is not able to travel very fast and may hold back the entire group.

#3
S4E18 8.9
Weight of Command

Bill and Major Adams plan on going hunting with a friend but when he is not home they suspect a renegade party of Cheyenne who have broken the peace treaty and the wagon train may be their next target.

#4 The John Gillman Story S8E3 8.9
#5 The Mary Ellen Thomas Story S2E12 8.8
#6 The Christopher Hale Story S4E25 8.8
#7 The Robert Harrison Clarke Story S7E5 8.8
#8 The Tobias Jones Story S2E4 8.7
#9 The Ella Lindstrom Story S2E18 8.7
#10 The Andrew Hale Story S2E35 8.7

Lowlights

#284 S8E17 The Isaiah Quickfox Story 4.6

Coop and Charlie ride into a small village for supplies finding it deserted. There is an Indian who stays hidden and later three men and a woman ride into town. They have been looking for the woman's father in a cave filled with bats.

#283 Princess of a Lost Tribe S4E6 5.5
#282 The Betsy Blee Smith Story S8E22 6.1
#281 The Ah Chong Story S4E37 6.3
#280 The Hector Heatherton Story S8E13 6.4

The Quality Arc

Each point is an episode, plotted in order. Colored bands mark season boundaries. Look for the rise, the plateau, or the decline.

Loading chart...

Episode Engagement

High votes + high rating = beloved classic. High votes + low rating = notorious stinker. Low votes + high rating = hidden gem.

Loading chart...

Series Trajectory

One point per season. Smooths out the episode-to-episode noise to reveal the bigger arc.

Loading chart...

Season Momentum

Did each season build or fizzle? Green means the finale outscored the premiere. Red means the opposite. Longer arrows, bigger swings.

Loading chart...

Season Consistency

How steady is each season? Tightly clustered dots mean reliable quality. Scattered dots mean a wild ride.

Loading chart...