Episode Ratings Grid

M
Loading chart...
Great
Good
Mid
Bad

Episode Power Rankings

The peaks and the valleys. Find the essential episodes — and the ones to skip.

#1
S6E24 8.8
The Handy Man

A legal fight over a strip of land between Shiloh and the Bowden ranch turns nasty. The fight over cools when the Bowdens mistakenly believe Shiloh has hired a gunfighter but turns serious when they learn he is just a simply handy man.

#2
S2E1 8.7
Ride a Dark Trail

The Virginian, trying to calm a rampaging boy, shares the story of Trampas' gambling father who reformed. That father tried to reform Trampas before Garth was forced to kill him in self-defense, setting Trampas on a quest for vengeance.

#3
S6E25 8.7
The Decision

Sheriff Dan Porter leaves his job in Mason City to follow his wife Emily to Medicine Bow as she can't handle the pressure of his job. He signs on at Shiloh to learn ranching so he can start a ranch and new life with his wife.

#4 The Accomplice S1E13 8.6
#5 Show Me a Hero S4E9 8.6
#6 Last Grave at Socorro Creek S7E16 8.6
#7 Holocaust S8E17 8.6
#8 The Sins of the Fathers S8E22 8.6
#9 Showdown S3E29 8.5
#10 Jacob Was a Plain Man S5E5 8.5

Lowlights

#249 S9E2 The Best Man 5.2

Trampas and Pick Lexington visit old friends in Mexico. Trampas is caught between Pick and one of his Mexican friends as both men fall for the same girl. He hopes to stop them from dueling each other while the girl chooses between them.

#248 Nightmare S8E16 5.9
#247 The Legacy of Spencer Flats S9E17 6.0
#246 The Death Wagon S6E16 6.3
#245 One Spring Like Long Ago S4E24 6.5

The Quality Arc

Each point is an episode, plotted in order. Colored bands mark season boundaries. Look for the rise, the plateau, or the decline.

Loading chart...

Episode Engagement

High votes + high rating = beloved classic. High votes + low rating = notorious stinker. Low votes + high rating = hidden gem.

Loading chart...

Series Trajectory

One point per season. Smooths out the episode-to-episode noise to reveal the bigger arc.

Loading chart...

Season Momentum

Did each season build or fizzle? Green means the finale outscored the premiere. Red means the opposite. Longer arrows, bigger swings.

Loading chart...

Season Consistency

How steady is each season? Tightly clustered dots mean reliable quality. Scattered dots mean a wild ride.

Loading chart...