Episode Ratings Grid

M
Loading chart...
Great
Good

Episode Power Rankings

The peaks and the valleys. Find the essential episodes — and the ones to skip.

#1
S1E8 8.0
The Verdict

Is Michael Peterson guilty or not guilty? The jury delivers its verdict regarding the mysterious death of his wife, Kathleen.

#2
S1E10 7.7
The Last Chance

After more experts testify about the questionable conclusions and claims of Duane Deaver, the judge rules on whether a new trial is necessary.

#3
S1E5 7.6
A Weak Case

The prosecution presents its case while the defense strives to cast a reasonable doubt within the minds of the jury.

#4 The Blowpoke Returns S1E7 7.6
#5 Flawed Justice S1E13 7.6
#6 A Prosecution Trickery S1E4 7.5
#7 The Prosecution's Revenge S1E6 7.5
#8 Reopening the Case S1E9 7.5
#9 Crime or Accident? S1E1 7.4
#10 Secrets and Lies S1E2 7.4

Lowlights

#13 S1E11 Looking For Closure 7.2

Following two and a half years of house arrest, Michael must decide whether to push for a plea or risk his freedom with a new trial.

#12 Between Despair and Anger S1E12 7.3
#11 A Striking Coincidence S1E3 7.4
#10 Secrets and Lies S1E2 7.4
#9 Crime or Accident? S1E1 7.4

The Quality Arc

Each point is an episode, plotted in order. Colored bands mark season boundaries. Look for the rise, the plateau, or the decline.

Loading chart...

Episode Engagement

High votes + high rating = beloved classic. High votes + low rating = notorious stinker. Low votes + high rating = hidden gem.

Loading chart...