#1
S1E5
Peace in Our Time
Gilbert learns about Bodkin's shady dealings. Dove stirs up trouble at the pub. With new evidence, the crew pieces together a shocking narrative.
Episode Ratings Grid
M
Loading chart...
Good
If You Liked This
See AllEpisode Power Rankings
The peaks and the valleys. Find the essential episodes — and the ones to skip.
#2
S1E3
Perfectly Innocent Life
The group digs for more clues after a beloved local's death. New details about the Samhain disappearances force Dove to wade through murky territory.
#3
S1E4
Poison or Something
The crew's investigation takes a bizarre turn, jeopardizing their podcast. Gilbert attempts to settle a debt, while Dove gives Emmy harsh advice.
#4
Empty Your Pockets
S1E7
#5
Who We Are
S1E2
#6
Ends Justify Means
S1E6
#7
One True Mystery
S1E1
Lowlights
A hard-nosed journalist grudgingly works with a true-crime podcaster on a strange case in a small Irish town where the locals want to bury the past.
#6
Ends Justify Means
S1E6
#5
Who We Are
S1E2
#4
Empty Your Pockets
S1E7
#3
Poison or Something
S1E4
The Quality Arc
Each point is an episode, plotted in order. Colored bands mark season boundaries. Look for the rise, the plateau, or the decline.
Loading chart...
Episode Engagement
High votes + high rating = beloved classic. High votes + low rating = notorious stinker. Low votes + high rating = hidden gem.
Loading chart...