Episode Ratings Grid

M
Loading chart...
Great
Good
Mid

Episode Power Rankings

The peaks and the valleys. Find the essential episodes — and the ones to skip.

#1
S1E13 8.2
Whistler's Mother

It's election day. Most of the family is at Alison's campaign headquarters, both as a measure of support to Alison and as it is perhaps the safest place from an attack by SBK's accomplice being so public. There are two conspicuously absent family members: Madeline, who may no longer be welcome based on the confrontation she and Alison had; and Alison herself, she who has missed some key engagements on this important day, and who is not picking up her cell phone. Alison's absence worries the family, as she being possibly abducted by the accomplice. As Tessa passes this news to Brady, he and Cutter may have to work fast to discover who the accomplice is, they knowing that it is SBK's daughter, who would now be in her thirties and may have worked her way into a position of trust within the Hawthorne family circle. While most of the family is at campaign headquarters, Madeline is oblivious to what is happening being self sequestered at home with her private security detail, which may prove not to be the most secure location as the accomplice has proven in the past to be able to get in and out of the house easily. Meanwhile, Garrett and Christina are able to reconnect at the campaign HQ. Garrett may have to make a difficult decision based on what Christina tells him. And Cam, who through the lawyer hired by Madeline has basically cut all ties with Sophie including filing for sole custody of Jack, is happily in a platonic relationship with April. However, on this day, he has to provide some comfort to his son who still pines for his mother. Through all these issues, the discovery of who SBK's daughter and thus accomplice is may not be as straightforward as it appears on the surface.

#2
S1E11 7.9
Freedom from Fear

Garrett and Madeline are finally revealing all the old secrets and the mysterious events that took place in their house

#3
S1E12 7.8
Madame X

Because of Madeline and Garrett coming clean about the events of the night of David Morales' murder as they know it (or purport to know it), Brady has no other option but to charge them for their various crimes. They assisting and cooperating in the on-going investigation as to SBK's identity and his accomplice could help their cause in the long run. The one favor Garrett asks in return is to be able to contact Christina in whatever form so that she can hear the story directly from him rather than through a third party. In general, the family and the police believe the safest place for them away from whoever SBK's accomplice is at the house. In the process of safeguarding the house, Alison discovers more about the events not only of that night but also about the recent deaths of her father and Jennifer Windham, these discoveries which could further affect the family dynamic. Alison also gets a telephone call from Naomi, who she has to decide if she will let back into at least her professional life in light of she being mired in SBK and the imminent election, which she still has a chance of winning..., that is if certain information stays in the closet. The one person who decides not to stay at the house is Cam, who believes he knows what is safest for him and Jack. Cam may regret his decision.

#4 The Chess Players S1E6 7.6
#5 The Oxbow S1E9 7.6
#6 The Veteran in a New Field S1E10 7.6
#7 The Gross Clinic S1E7 7.4
#8 The Artist in His Museum S1E5 7.3
#9 Kindred Spirits S1E8 7.3
#10 Arrangement in Grey and Black S1E1 7.1

Lowlights

#13 S1E3 Nighthawks 6.9

Brady divulges to Tessa, who in turn tells the family, that new evidence in the Silver Bells Murder case is that he has a photograph of Cam as a teenager wearing the distinctive belt like the one that was discovered as evidence in the collapsed tunnel. Brady believes the easiest course of action to clear Cam if the photograph does come to light to his superiors is to get a sample of Cam's DNA, a request which Cam is advised by the family not to oblige. Brady has to decide if he will take measures against Tessa's wishes in getting that DNA sample. Alison and Naomi believe they can get the support of New England Patriot Stephen Gostkowski, which would ensure an election victory. The campaign event announcing that support takes a turn with an unexpected guest. Madeline continues to take control of the situation, now that she is the owner of Hawthorne Concrete. She also believes that Gunther may be problematic. Jack's latest action leads to Cam finally agreeing to get Jack some therapy. That initial pre-therapy meeting with Dr. Stanhope, who was Cam's own therapist when he was a minor, leads to Cam coming to a realization that some old evidence could be more incriminating than Brady's evidence of the photo. What Cam decides to do could be problematic for Alison. And Garrett runs into his old girlfriend, Molly, the two who have not seen each other since he ran off fourteen years ago at a stage in their relationship when they were talking of marriage. Unanswered questions may trump the sparks that still exist between the two.

#12 Jack-in-the-Pulpit S1E2 6.9
#11 Christina's World S1E4 7.0
#10 Arrangement in Grey and Black S1E1 7.1
#9 Kindred Spirits S1E8 7.3

The Quality Arc

Each point is an episode, plotted in order. Colored bands mark season boundaries. Look for the rise, the plateau, or the decline.

Loading chart...

Episode Engagement

High votes + high rating = beloved classic. High votes + low rating = notorious stinker. Low votes + high rating = hidden gem.

Loading chart...