Episode Ratings Grid

M
Loading chart...
Great
Good
Mid

Episode Power Rankings

The peaks and the valleys. Find the essential episodes — and the ones to skip.

#1
S4E5 8.2
Money, Moguls and Murder

A 2007 cold case resurfaces when a detective reopens the investigation into the brutal killing of Audrey Giannotti, 20, in rural Pennsylvania. Uncovering hidden secrets, he races against time to bring justice to a family desperate for answers.

#2
S1E8 8.0
A Family Secret

Ten years after a 17-year-old girl is found strangled in the woods in small-town Kentucky, detectives uncover a terrible family secret.

#3
S4E8 8.0
A Bullet to the Heart

When the body of a woman turns up in a field in Huntington Beach, CA in 1968, police simultaneously seek a killer and the identity of the victim herself. It takes 52 years for detectives to solve this dual mystery and expose a vicious predator.

#4 Evil in Huntington Beach S4E6 7.9
#5 Sweethearts, Silenced S1E4 7.8
#6 Viciously Murdered S4E9 7.8
#7 She Never Came Home S1E3 7.7
#8 Little Girl Lost S1E1 7.6
#9 Good Girl Gone S4E2 7.6
#10 Sooner State Nightmare S4E11 7.6

Lowlights

#60 S3E3 Murder in the Midwest 6.2

In September 1974 in Ohio, 15-year-old Lori Nesson disappeared while walking home from a high school football game after-party. Her naked body is found in a ditch the next day yet is ruled undetermined natural causes. The search for her killer finally begins when the cause of death is changed to homicide 40 years later.

#59 Gone in a New York Minute S3E2 6.2
#58 Vanished in Virginia S3E5 6.4
#57 Death of a Hero S3E4 6.4
#56 A is for Arson S2E23 6.4

The Quality Arc

Each point is an episode, plotted in order. Colored bands mark season boundaries. Look for the rise, the plateau, or the decline.

Loading chart...

Episode Engagement

High votes + high rating = beloved classic. High votes + low rating = notorious stinker. Low votes + high rating = hidden gem.

Loading chart...

Series Trajectory

One point per season. Smooths out the episode-to-episode noise to reveal the bigger arc.

Loading chart...

Season Momentum

Did each season build or fizzle? Green means the finale outscored the premiere. Red means the opposite. Longer arrows, bigger swings.

Loading chart...

Season Consistency

How steady is each season? Tightly clustered dots mean reliable quality. Scattered dots mean a wild ride.

Loading chart...